How do coaches summarise

A coaching notebook on a wooden desk with notes about summarising in coaching, alongside coaching books, a pen, glasses, coffee and a plant.
Share This Post

Are summaries in coaching a good thing? It is one of those areas where opinions are divided. Some books and coaches swear by summaries. And others avoid them strictly. Let’s explore if there is a definitive answer, and what the pros and cons of each approach may be.

Summarising in coaching: what is it?

By summaries, we mean a number of things:

  • A brief response to coachee monologues. One or two sentences.
  • A neutral response to them, without interpretation or analysis
  • A preamble to the coach’s next question

As many of us have the habit of talking too much, doing this well takes a degree of effort and skill! It is easy for our brief and neutral summaries to become laboured rambles.

What is the purpose of summarising in coaching?

There are a number of things that coaches are looking to achieve in summaries. They are about both the coachee, and the coach! These include:

  • Checking in on what has been said, to make sure there is a good understanding
  • Making sense of a large amount of content, especially after long monologues by the coachee
  • Summarising to bring out unifying themes from coachee monologues
  • Naming a feeling or a behaviour that has been heard
  • Providing their own reflective space before asking their next question

All of these are good reasons to summarise, if we can do it well!

What are the benefits of a coach summarising well?

If we do this well, the coachee will feel heard. They will know that their words have made sense to the ocachee, and will be encouraged to continue talking. Also, they may hear back in the summary things that they weren’t aware that they were saying:

Coach: “you’ve had a challenging year, with 2 changes of personnel, long hours to work and some job insecurity. You describe all this as “interesting”

Coachee: “blimey, I didn’t know I said “interesting”!

The brief summary may also provide time for the coachee to deepen their thinking, and allow new thoughts to emerge.

From the coach’s perspective, a summary may be just what they need to do. It may help them externalise their own thoughts and to hear them. And it may help them to develop a more powerful question than if they don’t summarise.

All in all, some good reasons for summarising, if it is done well.

And what are the risks, even if the coach summarises well?

Put simply, a summary can be a distraction! It can slow down the deepening of the thoughts of the coachee, just by them stopping their talking. It can also be like an approval cue. The coach summary can be seen as a validation or approval of what the coachee has said.

It can also distract. The coachee may start analysing the summary, wondering how accurate it is. Perhaps they will look to see if there are interpretations by the coach. Or will speculate on hidden meanings by the coach. Or they may wonder why the coach summarised one part of what they said, but not another part.

And finally, it may simply not be necessary. It may be fine, but may not add anything of value. This could leave the coachee feeling frustrated “why do they keep summarising?”

Summarising is one of the many things that we teach on our ILM coach training programmes.

Impact of summarising

This little table shows the potential impact of a summary on the coachee. It is clear that good summaries can raise awareness, but they can also distract

A personal perspective on summarising

When I first was trained, in 2007, I was taught to always summarise, so that’s what I did. Slavishly. Summarising, checking that my understanding was correct, then asking my next question. I was happy with that – then!

When I did my ICF training I had a change of heart. I listened to some advance coaching sessions, and noticed that there were rarely summaries being given. I asked one coach why she didn’t summarise, and she said: “I didn’t need to. I wasn’t confused!”

That set me on the road to thinking about whether I should summarise or not. I read lots round the topic, and only found information about how to summarise well. I couldn’t find anything on not summarising! I experimented with not summarising, and was much happier with that approach.

In the last few years, the pendulum has swung back to the centre for me! Mostly I don’t summarise and don’t feel a need to. But I am aware that, with absolutely no summaries, the session may sound a bit harsh and interrogative. I also find that there are times that a summary really can impact and make a difference. So my approach now is to mostly not summarise, but have the occasional one for impact and variety.

Next steps for coaches on summarising

Summarising in coaching is one of the areas where there is more than one possible approach. We can be great coaches and never summarise. Or we can be great coaches and often summarise. The most important thing is: whichever approach we take, do it well! If we are skilled summarisers, the negative impact will be minimised.

Summarising is one of the core coaching skills, alongside listening and questioning, and we also explore different questioning approaches for coaches.

What approach do you take? And how may this article influence you? We’d love to know!

Happy coaching and happy summarising!

If you were stimulated by this article and want to know more about how to use coaching for your career, your organisation or your life generally, then get in contact with us

We look forward to hearing from you! 

Charlie1

Charlie Warshawski is a leadership coach and coach trainer. He runs an accredited coach training organisation, Love Your Coaching, offering coaching qualifications. In his coaching, he works 1:1 with leaders, business owners and entrepreneurs, supporting them on topics that are both professional and personal – according to their needs 

Subscribe to this blog and receive it fortnightly in your inbox

An empty classroom with a large board, three clocks on the wall, and sunlight coming through the windows
Coaching in the education sector

Benefits of school leaders adopting a coaching approach

There are increasing opportunities for school leaders to learn how to become coaches and to adopt A coaching approach. We celebrate this, and look at some of the benefits of the school leader coach.

Photo of a person taking note - Love Your coaching
Coaching in organisations

360 feedback debrief – how to do it in coaching style

Is it possible to have a coaching session, debriefing the 360* feedback that our coachee received? It is, but it is full of pitfalls. Read on for ways to avoid these and make it a valuable experience for our coachee.